The more traveling I do, the more wise I become (gerbie) wrote,
The more traveling I do, the more wise I become
gerbie book reviews

I have noted something weird about the review system at Amazon. I have put a few dozens (85 actually) of my reviews on the English version of that site as well. They have been written for LJ, but could be used there as well.

I almost forgot about them, then I saw the system of reviewer-ranking. Apparently I am ranked 1749 now. I got 126 helpful votes. Looking at people who are equally ranked 1749, I notice most of them have got less helpful votes. I assume I got a lot of ‘not helpful’ votes as well. This was confirmed when I looked through the reviews I wrote.

Something peculiar came up. When I enjoyed a book and wrote positively about it, I get plenty votes. If I didn’t like the book and hence wrote a not very nice review, I get a lot of negative votes. Looking at the books that got five or more votes, this was almost 100% true. Only 3 books do not fit one of the categories. Exactly the three that were not outspoken positive or negative.

Yet I feel that a clear review (positive or negative) is always good. If someone didn’t like the book at all, I like reading about it. Do you have to be positive all the time to become a good/popular reviewer?

My three categories.

I loved them:

Isabel Allende – Retrato en sepia (10 from 11)
Iain Banks – The wasp factory (5 from 5 and 7 of 7)
Brian Thacker – Rule no. 5: No sex on the bus (5 of 5)
Gabriel Garcia Marquez – One hundred years of solitude (9 of 11)
Charles Dickens – Oliver Twist (5 of 5)
John Reed – Ten days that shook the world (7 of 8)
Bill Bryson – Down Under (4 of 5)

Didn’t like them:

Bridget Jones – The edge of reason (2 out of 7)
Lance Armstrong – it is not about the bike (1 of 16)
Stephen Fry – Moab is my washpot (1 of 9)
Anthony Burgess – A clockwork Orange (0 of 8)
Arthur Miller – Death of a salesmen (1 of 5)


Mikail Bulgakov – The master and Margarita (3 of 6)
Arundhati Roy – The god of small things (2 of 8)
Leopold Sacher-Masoch – Venus in Furs (5 of 7)

P.s. I do not know how to link to individual reviews, but I have reviewed all these and 70 other books using my usual nick: gerbie7
  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 1 comment